In their own words.
Witness Lee on salvation, the high gospel, and calling on the Lord. Elders on Philip Lee and Anaheim. Former members on money, control, and dissent. For a shorter summary, see the ten tests Witness Lee’s teaching fails.
45 quoted passages
How authority shaped the Local Churches
Claims about God’s oracle
“You cannot deny the fact that the Lord’s oracle has been with me. I claim this at the face of Jesus Christ.”
“I’m claiming this for Lee!”
“If you listen to me, you do not listen to Lee, you listen to the very God in His oracle spoken by me.”
Philip Lee, Timothy Lee, and accountability
Authority, misconduct, and discipline
“She could not tolerate anymore the gross misconduct that was being perpetrated upon some and especially upon her.”
“It is contended that “gross immorality” and other sins were committed by Phillip Lee over a ten-year period, with Witness Lee’s knowledge, and that Lee and his co-workers tolerated and covered up this behavior.”
“Philip was observed fondling a sister in the office of Living Stream.”
“Philip, of course, is not perfect; nobody is perfect!”
The Daystar business
“He was known to have had a prostitute stay with him.”
“Later the son mentioned to some saints that 2.5 million U. S. dollars disappeared from his hands.”
“Many saints were pressured to give their life savings to this business.”
“Mr. X then asked one of his co-workers … to persuade the saints, who invested their money to consider the investment as a donation and not seek to be reimbursed.”
“Most were intimidated into taking a big bath.”
“Ones who were quite angry and wanted their money back, typically, got paid.”
“They have lost their virginity.”
“Why, the “little precious man” sitting right in front of us, IS THE MAN who seduced us all!!”
Financial questions involving the Lee family
“About Daystar, that is not your business. No, I don’t answer you.”
“I’m not responsible to anyone. I’m only responsible to the government.”
“Philip Lee and the grandsons of Lee had fat Swiss bank accounts.”
Taiwan, 1959: the pattern before Daystar
“Around 1959, Lee’s private mishandling of finances caused the first financial crisis. The work funds the saints had offered were lost, and a large debt remained. Coworkers were forced to sell a roughly seven-thousand-ping plot on Nanking East Road that had been purchased for a meeting hall and training center.”
“The work funds were entrusted to him by the Lord, he said, and he had the right to dispose of them as he pleased. Even if he threw them into the Pacific Ocean, no one had the right to question him.”
“This is exactly the situation of Amos 8:5: using a small measure when giving out and a large one when taking in, and cheating with dishonest scales.”
The pattern did not stop with Daystar
“Because the motor home market stopped, so it turned to the factory … manufacturing tennis racquets.”
“The funds collected by Living Stream for Linkou were neither forwarded to the church in Taipei nor returned to the contributing churches.”
“Toward the roughly NT$30 million Linkou purchase, Taiwan Gospel Book Room contributed NT$3 million, then at registration demanded a one-tenth ownership stake in the property.”
“We have bought more than twenty-four acres of land in Linkou, and we hope to be able to build a large meeting hall, but our application for the building permit was not approved.”
“Have you heard about Lee’s other financial swindles? Anyone remember the tennis racket factory? I think it was called “Delta.” … We had to cart around dozens of boxes of unsellable tennis rackets every time we moved.”
God, Christ, salvation, and the kingdom
Christ became the life-giving Spirit
“In resurrection Christ as the last Adam became the life-giving Spirit and entered into His believers as the Holy Spirit.”
“We may say that the Son is the Father (Isa. 9:6), and that the Spirit is the Son (2 Cor. 3:17).”
“It is heretical to teach that there are two life-giving Spirits, two Spirits who give life.”
“Before Christ’s resurrection, such a Spirit was not yet. Christ’s resurrection produced the life-giving Spirit.”
The Son, the Father, and “one person”
“The Father, the Son, and the Spirit are not three separate persons or three Gods; they are one God, one reality, one person.”
When a trainer placed Lee after the Trinity
“We agree that this leading is indispensable to our oneness.”
“We preach that Witness Lee is a one-man show.”
“The Father is first, the Son second, the Holy Spirit third, Witness Lee fourth, followed by those around Witness Lee.”
“The Triune God is three, yet He now has a fourth part, a counterpart.”
Is “one church in one city” a biblical command?
“Each mention of the city-church in scripture is a description, an example, and does not involve commands.”
“Regardless of how they deny it, every no-name group eventually is named, and perhaps even more strongly than those around it.”
When Lee called the apostles’ gospel “low”
“We should not preach the shallow gospel that Christianity preaches. That gospel tells people that they have sinned and must suffer the punishment of hell, but that God has had pity on them and has given His beloved Son to die for them to redeem them and to resurrect for them, and that as long as they repent and believe in Him, they will receive eternal life and will go to heaven... Although this is the gospel, it is a low gospel. The high gospel that we preach says that the Word who was God from the beginning became flesh, passed through human living, was crucified, resurrected, and has become the life-giving Spirit to accomplish the great work of the divine dispensing.”
Witness Lee and the Gnostics
“Animal men, again, are instructed in animal things; such men, namely, as are established by their works, and by a mere faith, while they have not perfect knowledge. We of the Church, they say, are these persons.”
“Today many Christians can be compared to cows listening to music: they have no appreciation or discernment of what they hear.”
Psalm 1 and the plain words of Scripture
“This shows us that Psalm 1 is good, but it was written with a wrong concept… Thus, we should not highly appraise Psalm 1. It was written wrongly with a wrong concept, a human concept.”
“In verses 1-6, he was ‘Abel’; in verses 7-11, he was ‘Cain.’ We have to give David the credit in the line of life and the debit in the line of the knowledge of good and evil.”
“The book of Job, preceding the Psalms, is a record of human views based on human concepts concerning the relationship between God and man… In this book there is no prayer or praise offered to God. Furthermore, there is no hint that Job, his three friends, and Elihu had any kind of thirst for God.”
“When, however, they are confuted from the Scriptures, they turn round and accuse these same Scriptures, as if they were not correct, nor of authority, and [assert] that they are ambiguous, and that the truth cannot be extracted from them by those who are ignorant of tradition.”
Easy believism and calling "O Lord" three times
“If we help them to say “O Lord” three times, they will be saved.”
15Moreover if your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault between you and him alone. If he hears you, you have gained your brother.
16But if he will not hear, take with you one or two more, that “by the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.”
17And if he refuses to hear them, tell it to the church. But if he refuses even to hear the church, let him be to you like a heathen and a tax collector.
Jesus does not leave an unrepentant brother inside the fellowship forever. After private confrontation and witnesses, the church speaks plainly. If he still refuses to turn back, he is to be treated as an unbeliever and a tax collector, that is, as someone outside the believing community. The quotations above document protected sin, resisted correction, and teaching many Christians judge to be another gospel. Members who have brought these concerns to leaders and heard no repentance are not required to remain in the Local Churches as though Witness Lee and his ministry were still a faithful church.